Download E-books Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy) PDF

By Scott G. Schreiber

Proposing the 1st book-length research in English of Aristotle s Sophistical Refutations, this paintings takes a clean examine this seminal textual content on fake reasoning. via a cautious and significant research of Aristotle s examples of sophistical reasoning, Scott G. Schreiber explores Aristotle s reason for his taxonomy of twelve fallacy forms. opposite to sure sleek makes an attempt to lessen all incorrect reasoning to both blunders of logical shape or linguistic imprecision, Aristotle insists that, as very important as shape and language are, particular types of fake reasoning derive their persuasiveness from fallacious ideals concerning the nature of language and the character of the world."

Show description

Read or Download Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy) PDF

Similar Ancient Greece books

The Histories

Translated by way of Aubrey de Sélincourt with an advent and Notes through John M. Marincola. For greater than seventy years, Penguin has been the best writer of vintage literature within the English-speaking international. With greater than 1,700 titles, Penguin Classics represents a world bookshelf of the simplest works all through heritage and throughout genres and disciplines.

Demosthenes and His Time: A Study in Defeat

This publication attracts on quite a lot of facts to check the background of Athens from 386 to 322 B. C. Taking a sympathetic view of the second one Athenian League, Sealey makes a speciality of the occupation of Demosthenes to supply vital insights into Athenian politics and guidelines. Demosthenes skilled repeated setbacks in his early makes an attempt at public job, yet chanced on his undertaking as a statesman within the clash with Macedon and as a consequence turned the top guy in Athens.

Greek Comedy and Ideology

In comedy, satisfied endings unravel real-world conflicts. those conflicts, in flip, depart their mark at the texts within the kind of gaps in plot and inconsistencies of characterization. Greek Comedy and beliefs analyzes how the constitution of historical Greek comedy betrays and responds to cultural tensions within the society of the classical city-state.

The Poetry of Sappho

This present day, millions of years after her beginning, in lands distant from her local island of Lesbos and in languages that didn't exist whilst she wrote her poetry in Aeolic Greek, Sappho continues to be an immense identify between enthusiasts of poetry and poets alike,. Celebrated all through antiquity because the preferrred Greek poet of affection and of the private lyric, famous in particular for her limpid fusion of formal poise, lucid perception, and incandescent ardour, this present day her poetry is additionally prized for its uniquely bright participation in a residing paganism.

Additional info for Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy)

Show sample text content

Such, even though, was once no longer consistently the case. From the early Greek commentators, throughout the Latin schoolmen of the medieval interval, and into the 19th century, there were a gentle curiosity within the venture of constructing a whole taxonomy of reasoning blunders. Why did this curiosity wane within the 20th century? One issue is that the so-called linguistic flip in xiii xiv PREFACE the Anglo-American philosophic international might not heavily entertain Aristotle’s leader taxonomical contrast among blunders in response to language and blunders established open air of language. The efforts of those philosophers, no matter if proponents of normal or perfect language, have been to unravel philosophic difficulties completely via linguistic clarification. the belief that this is able to be performed left little sympathy for Aristotle’s declare that yes sorts of fake reasoning, themselves efficient of philosophical perplexities desiring solution, might in simple terms be resolved via metaphysical clarification. This publication returns, with significant sympathy, to Aristotle’s venture. My aim is to clarify the philosophical justification that Aristotle offers for his classification of fallacies. to do that, besides the fact that, it is vital to discover in a few aspect the varied examples of fallacies that Aristotle makes use of for representation. As occurs so frequently in Aristotle, his examples can either make clear and confuse. a lot of this e-book consists of a detailed research of those often-elliptical illustrations of fake reasoning. I realize that there's a hazard in treating so heavily all of those examples. The reader may well start to lose sight of Aristotle’s great photograph: his justification of the final taxonomy. If one does sometimes find oneself wasting sight of the wooded area for the bushes, i am hoping that the bushes themselves are sufficiently interesting, supplying peripheral insights into different parts of logical concept and wider Aristotelian inspiration. This have to be aware of Aristotle’s examples explains specific positive factors of the learn: the wide Greek citations and the sparing use of non-English secondary resources. i've got attempted to maintain the publication as available as attainable to the “Greekless” reader. a lot of what Aristotle says is essential to readers essentially within the heritage of good judgment or within the growing to be smooth literature on casual fallacies. hence, i've got used my very own translations of all of the Greek references. however, I even have incorporated (most frequently within the notes) huge citations of Aristotle’s Greek. I owe this to these Greek readers of the e-book, simply because such a lot of of Aristotle’s fallacies are seriously established upon beneficial properties of the Greek language. an additional results of this dependency is that any translation of Aristotle’s examples from Greek into one other language could have significant effects of both clarifying or obfuscating the fallacy being exemplified. in addition, various sleek languages will produce diverse changes. What occurs to Aristotle’s examples once they are rendered into German or French provides an additional layer of difficulty for the English reader attempting to take hold of Aristotle’s conception.

Rated 4.06 of 5 – based on 34 votes